Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Transcendence

Where do I begin?

I can't decide if I liked Transcendence or not. 

The movie,  in and of itself, is gorgeous.  Every single shot is framed beautifully.  There is no doubt on my mind that director Wally Pfister gives a lot of attention to the visual aspects of his movies.

That being said,  Transcendence was terrifying.

Most of us have probably heard theories about the demise of the technical age.  People have been planning for this for years,  the most recent example that I can think of being Y2K.  

Some say a solar flare will knock out the grid.  Some say one of our enemies will pull the plug on us and leave us in darkness.  Some say it will be a conspiracy spearheaded by an overly controlling government that will cut off our power. Transcendence says that we'll bring it on ourselves.  That in our efforts to enhance ourselves through technology,  we will destroy it.

Early on,  we meet Will Caster and his wife Evelyn (played by Johnny Depp and Rebecca Hall respectively), who have devoted themselves to creating a sentient computer, one that can function like a human and think for itself.   So far, they have been successful in the form of PINN, Physically Independent Neural Network.   However,  research continues at various science labs across the country to perfect the program.

Tragedy strikes when Will's affiliate labs are attacked, and he himself is shot at a convention.   Matters are further complicated when it is discovered that the bullet that shot Will was laced with Polonium, and Will only has a month to live.

Will decides to spend the last few weeks of his life home with Evelyn.  Evelyn, however,  isn't ready to accept Willis death so easily.   After finding out that one of their fellow scientists had successfully uploaded a monkey's consciousness to a computer,  she tries to convince Will and their friend Max (Paul Bettany) to attempt to do the same with Will's mind.  Max doesn't like the idea,  but Will decides it's worth a try (more for Evelyn ' s sake than his desire for the technology to work).

After Will dies in his sleep,  it appears that the process wasn't successful.   But as Evelyn and Max prepare to shut down the program,  they are surprised when a message appears on the screen: Is anyone there? 

Evelyn is convinced that it's Will, but Max has his doubts and insists they shut down the program anyway.  Furious,  Evelyn tells him to leave.  She uploads Will to the Internet,  and he leads her to a remote town in New Mexico where he instructs her to build a gigantic laboratory with the world's biggest array of satellite panels from which he can draw power.

Meanwhile,  Max is abducted by a group of anti-technology people called RIFT, Revolutionary Independence from Technology.   These are the guys behind the attacks on the science labs and for poisoning Will.  Their leader,  Bree (Kate Mara), tells him they agree with his misgivings about uploading humanity to computers, except they're taking it a step further by trying to end human dependence on technology altogether.   Max resists at first,  but later joins them.

Man vs.  Computer

What's interesting up to this point is the difference between the human-Will and the computerized-Will. 

Human-Will appears selfless,  and his only purpose is to aid humanity through his research and technical advancements.   When it comes down to a decision between spending the remainder of his life at work or with Evelyn,  he chooses Evelyn without question. 

Computerized-Will, on the other hand,  seems intent on conquest from the get-go.  He heals people with his advanced technology,  but in doing so he implants a bit of himself into them.  This way,  he builds himself a pseudo-zombified army with superhuman strength and the ability to heal, all controlled by his main computer systems.

Despite her love for Will, Evelyn is appalled by this.  She tolerates it for a while, but after Will reanimates his army after they are killed by RIFT guys,  she decides enough is enough.

At RIFT headquarters,  Max explains that he never believed it was possible to upload Will, himself,  to a computer.   He points out how the computerized-Will seems self-serving and controlling,  unlike the human-Will.   He convinces her that it's never really been Will in the computer. 

She agrees to help them shut him/it down.

The End...?

This is where things started getting really confusing for me. 

Evelyn injects herself with a computer virus that will shut down the computerized-Will and every network he's touched...which is everything.  Then she goes back to Will and asks him to upload her into his system.  During the ensuing battle between RIFT and Will's techno-zombified army,  Evelyn is wounded.  At first it doesn't seem like the computerized-Will cares, but later he tries to heal her (thus infecting him with the virus).  At the same time,  Evelyn says that she can "see" now.   Everything Will has done has, apparently,  been for good, to bring peace on Earth and save the planet.   Evelyn says she's sorry she didn't believe it was really Will, and they are later found dead in each others arms. 

My thing is, I'm still not really convinced it was really him.

As mentioned earlier,  the change in Will's human personality to his computerized personality is noticeable.   Human-Will puts Evelyn and her needs before his own.  Computerized-Will,  although he means well, is only concerned about accomplishing his goals.  

Human-Will, when given the choice between spending his last month at work in the lab or with Evelyn,  chooses to be with Evelyn.  There's a beautiful scene near the beginning where she's asleep in a lawn chair in their garden after working outside all day,  and Will comes up to her and carefully drapes a blanket over her.  Despite the fact that he's the one who's dying,  I think he is sad for her, that she will have to watch his decline and live on without him.

Computerized-Will is all about himself from the get-go.   "I need more power" he says almost right off the bat.  At first their lab in New Mexico is just big,  but as the film progresses it steadily gets bigger and bigger until it's insanely huge, even for a movie.  To top everything off, he doesn't understand why Evelyn isn't as excited about all of his advancements as he is.

"I don't understand," Will says.  "This is the future. "

"This is not our future, " Evelyn replies.   "You're not here with me."

"You've changed.  Have you fallen out of love with me?" he asks.

"No," she says.

The differences in Will's human and computerized personalities are so different from each other that I found it really hard to believe the computerized-Will was really Will to begin with.

Computers can't feel emotions.   They can only accomplish the tasks they are given.   And that is exactly what computerized-Will does.

However,  some would argue that Will really is himself because he really loves Evelyn.   But here's my argument against that: In the 8th (and most disturbing) season of Doctor Who, the Doctor states that true love isn't an emotion, it's a promise.  It makes sense,  doesn't it?   Most wedding vows says, " I take you to be my spouse,  to have and to hold from this day forward, in good times and bad, rich or poor,  in sickness and in health,  till death do us part."   Although love is important to the equation,  we aren't promising to have mushy feelings for each other all the time.   We're simply promise to stick together through everything.  

A computer can keep a promise, but it cannot feel love even if it wanted to.

And, to top off my argument,  one of the first things Will says when they upload him to the computer is, "I can't feel anything."

Tuesday, June 3, 2014

The Thorin Dilemma

THIS IS YOUR FIRST, FINAL, and ONLY WARNING!  THIS POST CONTAINS HOBBIT-RELATED SPOILERS.  IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE BOOK OR DON'T LIKE SPOILERS, DO NOT READ BELOW THE DOTTED LINE.

If you like spoilers or have read the book (or seen the cartoon) or know how the story ends by some other means, you may continue past the line.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Thorin Dilemma

Okay, so...apparently, someone started a petition to get Peter Jackson and company not to kill Thorin at the end of the 3rd Hobbit movie, to be released in December.  And apparently at least one of the Hobbit movie cast members has signed this petition (not Richard Armitage himself as far as I know).

It seems that certain die-hard Thorin Oakenshield fanatics who know how the story is supposed to end would rather have Peter Jackson commit the most foul of book-to-movie inaccuracies than allow Thorin to die.  

This wouldn't just be, "Oh, let's have a dwarf and an elf fall in love," or "Let's kill off Saruman at the beginning of the Return of the King so we don't have to deal with the Scouring of the Shire," or "Let's move the Palantir and Shelob's Lair to Return of the King instead of leaving it in Two Towers (where both episodes occur in the books)".  This is "We're not going to kill off a major character who is supposed to die just to make the fans happy."  

My initial response to the very idea of this was, "This would be the greatest atrocity in the history of Lord of the Rings/Hobbit movies!"


But, as I thought more and more about it, I found, to my surprise, that I'm actually quite torn over the issue.

Death of Thorin - everyone grab some tissues
As a massive accuracy freak and avid Tolkien fanatic, I want Thorin to die, if for no other reason than the fact that I want to see how Mr. Jackson and Company handle the final "farewell" conversation between Bilbo and Thorin.  

This conversation has always been one of those parts of the story that sticks with me, so I am anxious to see how it's executed in the film.

As sad as the scene is (and as much as I like the Richard Armitage's Thorin), I'm actually really looking forward to seeing Thorin's death scene in December, and I will be disappointed if it isn't there (although my Richard Armitage fangirl side will be secretly celebrating).  

Mr. Armitage and Mr. Freeman are very talented actors (as we've already seen in the past two movies).  

On top of that, Martin Freeman gave an absolutely gorgeous performance during the "suicide" and graveyard scenes at the end of the second season of BBC's Sherlock.  The "please don't be dead" scene is just beautifully executed.  Every Sherlock fan I've spoken with always goes on abut how much they love that scene, how moving it was, how sad they felt as Dr. Watson (aka Martin Freeman) delivered the line.  And I have to admit, I was moved by that scene (and by Mr. Freeman's performance in the scene) as well.

Oh, and then we have the already existing, "I have never been so wrong in all my life" line in Unexpected Journey, which was also executed beautifully between both actors.

So, we've got too very talented guys engaged in what I sincerely hope will be the most tear-jerking moment in the entire Hobbit trilogy.  I am thoroughly expecting to lose it in the theatre EVERY SINGLE TIME I see the movie.  

"LynZ, you're just being overdramatic," you might be thinking.  "You know what's coming, so you'll be fine."

That's what I thought too, until I watched Return of the King again back in February and was sobbing my eyes out before Frodo had even announced to his buddies that he was going with Bilbo and Gandalf and the rest on the boat at the Grey Havens.  Ever since then, I have thoroughly expecting to cry when Thorin dies...assuming Mr. Jackson doesn't cave to the demands of the aforementioned petition.   

But, as a Thorin Oakenshield fangirl, I don't want Thorin to die.  

It would be like killing off Luke Skywalker in The Empire Strikes Back.  You don't kill off Luke Skywalker in The Empire Strikes Back.  Fans would riot!

It would be like killing off Gale in Catching Fire.  Fangirls around the world would protest!

It would be like killing off Legolas in Fellowship of the Ring.  Let's not even begin to think about how the fangirls would react if that happened!


Admit it, some of you want this to happen!
My one and only defense for having Thorin live in the movie would be to have him return to Hobbiton several years down the road and meet baby Frodo.  From what we've seen so far, it's pretty clear that they've been trying to make an LOTR-prequel more than they're trying to make a movie of The Hobbit.  That is completely fine with me, actually, because The Hobbit is [technically] a prequel to LOTR.  Therefore, I think having a scene where Thorin meets Frodo as a child would be a great tie-in to the other three LOTR movies.  The great Thorin Oakenshield and the future Ring Bearer in the same room.  The boy who will one day save all of Middle Earth crawls up into the lap of the legendary King Under the Mountain, and Thorin smiles at him and makes some comments like, "This kid is destined for greatness."  

However, this tie-in could be accomplished with any of the remaining ten Dwarves.  In fact, I believe that in the book Balin comes to visit Bilbo several years later.  In Fellowship, when they find Balin's tomb in Moria, I think Frodo mentions him visiting when he was younger.  Now that I think about it, I believe Balin even shows up at the very end of The Hobbit (book).

Of course having a baby Frodo in the movie wouldn't be strictly accurate either because Frodo wasn't adopted until he was 21-ish.  But, Peter Jackson and company already messed up Frodo's age in the movie.  As much as I love Elijah Wood's Frodo, he isn't even remotely close to Frodo's age of fifty.  Tolkien clearly states that Frodo, Sam, and Pippin leave Bag End on Frodo's 50th birthday.  Elijah Wood turned 19 while they were filming the Hobbiton scenes for the movies.  19 and 50.  As one of my close friends would say, "Same, same...but different."  (You know who you are.)  

So, in the end, I guess I'm more in favor of having little kid Frodo in the movie than not having Thorin and Bilbo's farewell conversation after the Battle of Five Armies.  Having a little version of Frodo in the Hobbit movies would not only be a great tie-in to the LOTR movies, but also wouldn't be as great an atrocity as not letting Thorin die and giving him and Bilbo that beautiful conversation after the Battle of Five Armies.

Here's another thing to ponder.  

Why is there so little fan art depicting the death of Thorin Oakenshield?  

At any time, I can find more Thilbo fan art (which I find really disturbing) than fan art of Thorin's death in a "Thorin's Death" image search on Google or Pinterest.  I have found fan art based on Hobbit fan fiction in abundance, but no more than five images of Thorin's death.

Why is this?

No idea.

But, I have a theory.

I think some die-hard Thorin Oakenshield fans are afraid to image how this scene would play out or what it would look like.  We've read the book, and we know how deeply moved we were when Thorin passed away, and we're afraid to revisit those feelings.  Somehow, reading about it doesn't seem as bad as actually seeing it.  And in the movie theatre, it will be up close and personal.  

Someone on the Internet stated that if Jackson and company make this scene similar to Boromir's death, and Bilbo kisses Thorin's forehead seconds after his passing, that particular Hobbit/LOTR fan will completely lose it.  

I think those of us who dare to image what it will be like (in the upcoming movie) find that we're moved just by our perceptions of how the scene might play out.  The thought of seeing it might be emotionally distressing for some of us.  In which case, the idea that this scene will become up close and personal might be a little scary to some.  

I think this is, at least in part, why there is so little fan art depicting Thorin's death.

This theory may also be at the heart of the anti-Thorin's-death petition.

Maybe the aforementioned petition was created by the people who can't bear the thought of having to watch Thorin die after growing to love him so much during nearly six hours of previous screen time?  

I don't know for sure, but it's a possibility.

So, I guess this is my own little one-man "petition" to Mr. Jackson and Company:

LET THORIN DIE!

It's part of the original story, and I am sincerely looking forward to seeing how it plays out on screen in December (and I'm sure I'm not alone)!

Please, please, please don't rob us of this beautiful moment between Thorin and Bilbo!

Signed, 
LynZ Media Thoughts
http://lynzmediathoughts.blogspot.com


Rest in Peace, Thorin Oakenshield

Wednesday, May 14, 2014

Burning Panem

Recently, I realized that I've officially supported Christian movies, watched a Disney sing-along, and got caught up on my post-apocalyptic movies in a period of, like, 29 days.

March 27, 2014 - God's Not Dead

March 28, 2014 - Noah


April 11, 2014 - Divergent


April 19, 2014 - Heaven is for Real


April 20, 2014 - X-Files: Fight the Future

April 23, 2014 - Frozen


April 24, 2014 - Catching Fire



As a Christian, I feel it is important to support Christian movies (God's Not Dead, Heaven is for Real).


I was so sick and tired of hearing people gripe about Noah before it had actually opened that I went to see it to find out for myself if it was really all that bad.  (Read all about my Noah thoughts at: http://lynzmediathoughts.blogspot.com/2014/03/noah-splash-of-apocalypse.html).

So many people have harassed me about not seeing Frozen, that I finally caved in and watched it.  To one dear friend who was giving me a hard time, I said, "You haven't seen Desolation of Smaug.  I haven't seen Frozen.  We're equal."

Okay, my friend (you know who you are), I saw Frozen.  Now, it's your turn.

And I'm officially ready for X-Files: I Want to Believe, Insurgent, and Mockingjay Part 1!  Woo hoo!! 

I bet you're all wondering what I thought of all of the above movies, but I'm just going to focus on one of them for now.



Back in April 2012, a friend loaned me one of her two copies of The Hunger Games after learning (much to her distress) that I hadn't read the books up to that point.

I finished it in twelve days.

This was an unfathomable amount of time for avid readers who can finish an entire monster book in two or three sittings.

However, considering that I have always been a slow reader due to a lazy eye and an audio/visual processing difficulty, twelve days was a record for me (19 days being my previous record).

As it turned out, The Hunger Games was required reading for my college level creative writing class that Fall.  Funny how things work out sometimes.

So, when the movie-edition of the second book was released in October of 2013, I ordered it from Amazon ($7.50-something!).  As I'd learned when The Hunger Games and The Host came out, trying to rent a book of a popular new-release movie from the library is like having a tea party with Sasquatch.  You wait at the end of a five hundred person waiting list for three years, and by the time you finally get your hands on it, the third movie has already come out.  So, as I did with The Host, I bought the thing for myself.  And, as was my logic back then, "If I'm gonna buy the thing, I might as well get the copy with Jennifer Lawrence's face on it."

I made it to Chapter Eight before Ender's Game opened in theaters, and my other friend loaned me her copy of the book.  To date, I still haven't finished Catching Fire.


The Fire Starter


The Girl on Fire and the Boy with the Bread
Could it possibly be love?
In August 2012, I found myself among the masses madly seeking one renegade copy of The Hunger Games with Jennifer Lawrence (who I still believe must be distantly related to Anna Popplewell of Narnia fame).  I was competing with all the die-hard THGians and avowed Josh Hutcherson fangirls, so it took me almost two hours to obtain my coveted Blockbuster overnight rental copy of the movie.

Let it be known, my Dad HATES sad, violent movies (he doesn't understand why I like reading/watching sad or Holocaust related stories for this reason).  When I left to obtain my THG dvd, I explained that THG wasn't the sort of thing he'd like (kids killing kids isn't my idea of a fun family movie).  He said he understand.

When I returned after my "Hunger Quest", tired and footsore, he said, "Okay, let's start watching the movie while you eat dinner!"

He lasted all of twenty minutes.

They hadn't even left for the Capital, and he was like, "I'm done."

It's kinda sad to say that my reaction was, "But, they haven't even started killing each other yet!"

To date, I still haven't seen the end of The Hunger Games.  And not because my Dad stopped watching twenty minutes in.  I made it all the way to the end of the Games before my nausea became unbearable.  For most people, the unnecessarily shaky camera work that makes up the vast majority of the movie was just kind of distracting and annoying.  It made me motion sick.

Besides that, I was very disappointed by what I saw.

The soundtrack could have had a much more active role in the overall film.  Stephanie Meyers and her works may receive a large portion of criticism and pounding from my fellow Whovians, but at least The Host had an AMAZING soundtrack that really complimented the talents of Saoirse Ronan, Max Irons, Jake Abel, and Diane Kruger.

Meanwhile in Panem, everyone gathers for the Reaping, Prim's name gets called, Katniss volunteers, and Peeta gets selected...before the music finally decides to kick in.

And someone please explain the significance of that random scene where Katniss is playing with the habitat mode of the wallpaper in her Capital room?

And why, oh why, was the bread tossing scene in the rain so incredibly short?  Plus, it just kind of randomly shows up in the middle of a dinner scene, there's no dialogue, and I know for a fact that people who hadn't actually read the books had no idea what was going on.  I have a friend who's little sister was (or maybe still is) a Hutcherson fangirl.  Thus, my friend ended up seeing the movie when her when it came out back in March 2012.  After I told her about what was supposed to be happening in that scene, she said, "I didn't realize that scene was so important.  I thought [Katniss] was just sick or something."

Sick, sitting out under a tree in someone else's backyard, in the rain.  Makes perfect sense to throw some bread at her, right?  Yeah...no.

My two biggest complaints were the soundtrack and the shaky camera.

The cast was really good.  The sets and CGI were amazing.  If that stupid camera had held still for more that 2.7 consecutive seconds, I might have been able to enjoy it a little more.


Panem Catches [on] Fire (and burns...slowly)


The Mockingjay Revealed
Catching Fire really wasn't all that bad.

Note the fact that I know next to nothing about the story, as I got to chapter eight before giving up.


The things I do know about that I noticed have been changed were done so in a way that flows very well with the overall story.  None of it seems forced or jarring.  And the filmmakers actually used a tripod this time!  Therefore, I was finally able to enjoy a Hunger Games movie without almost getting sick to my stomach!  Thank you!  Thank you!  Thank you!

Maybe it's the new director?  Maybe it's the better, more active soundtrack?  Who knows.

One thing that really stood out to me throughout the film was how Jennifer Lawrence did a spectacular job of consistently portraying Katniss as emotionally disturbed by what she's experienced in the last Games.  She imagines that she's shooting at people when she's hunting.  She jumps and draws an arrow at every sound she hears.

There's a scene in particular that I'm watching right now when Peeta whacks a force field and "dies", but Finnick revives him.  The entire time, Katniss is crying and freaking out, to the point that once he's revived, she kisses him and hugs him (willingly, not just to make President Snow happy).  And she's shaking the entire time.  Which I thought was really realistic...until I remembered that it was really Jennifer Lawrence in a wetsuit in front of a camera with a very much alive Josh Hutcherson lying at her feet.  And then I was like, "Wow!  This lady is good!  How did I not notice this before now?"  Maybe because I couldn't make anything out through the shaky camera in the first movie?  Maybe because I haven't taken the time to watch Winter's Bone or X-Men: First Class yet?  Who knows.

The other thing I realized was the lack of bad language content.  I only remember two uses of objectionable language in the entire film (well, ok, maybe three).

1. Johanna, notably the most out of control character in the arena, shouts the F-word at the crowds during her pre-Games interview.  Mercifully, this is muted out so we don't actually hear her say it, but it's still pretty obvious what she's saying.

2. A mentally/emotionally strained Katniss freaks out at Haymitch after learning that one of her friends has been captured by the Capital.  During this epic Katniss freak-out scene, she slaps him and calls him, "You son of b----!"

3. There were, perhaps, a handful of "Oh God" and "Oh my God" uses splattered about in the film.

And while we're on the subject of Joahnna Mason, viewers should be warned of her "strip" scene.  Basically, she strips down in an elevator with Haymitch, Peeta, and Katniss present.  It's all filmed very carefully so that nothing more than a bare back and shoulders are shown, but it's still pretty obvious what's going on.  So, I guess that would be four moments of objectionable content that bothered me.

On a more positive note, did I already mention that Catching Fire and Desolation of Smaug have something in common?  Katniss and Bilbo both have "Tree Scenes", where they climb up trees to get a better view of something.


Katniss in a Tree Nov. 2013

Bilbo in a Tree, Dec. 2013

Either Katniss is pulling a Bilbo, or Bilbo is pulling Katniss.  I'm gonna say that Katniss is copying Bilbo, though, because The Hobbit (1937) was published WAY before Catching Fire (2009).  Sorry, Katniss. 


The Fire Hazard



Yes, my friends, Katniss Everdeen is a fire hazard.

And I don't mean in the way you think; that she's a danger to the Capital and the governmental [dictatorship] structure of Panem.

She's a fire hazard to herself.

She's a ticking time-bomb of insanity.  The only thing left to figure out is when.  Avid Hunger Games fans probably know.

Jennifer Lawrence, as mentioned before, did a phenomenal job of portraying Katniss' slow decline into insanity.  After all, how is a sixteen year old girl going to cope with the traumatic memories of the Games?

There's an icy silence between her and Peeta after the Games.  Gale isn't available very much anymore because he's now 19 and old enough to work in the coal mines for which District Twelve is "famous".  Her sister and mother certainly have no idea what she's going through, or how to help her. The only other victor is a drunk.  She could hunt, but every time she draws an arrow to shoot, she images she's killing someone again.

She's a combustible firebomb waiting for a spark.

On top of this, she's now a "beacon of hope" to the other districts.  On the one hand, people look to her with dreams of hope and freedom from the Capital...and especially from the Games.  On the other hand, she's got President Snow threatening her life and the lives of everyone she holds dear if she doesn't make the Districts believe she's just another victor like all the rest - and instrument of the Capital.

Of course, if this plan had gone accordingly, there wouldn't be a story here.

However, the plan does backfire, and soon all of the other Districts are in turmoil.  The Rebellion as started, and she is to be their Mockingjay.

I don't care what anybody says, but the weight of the world is too much for a sixteen or seventeen year old to handle.  Especially an emotionally distressed one such as our friend Katniss.

Admittedly, this is weight she never asked for.  She just wanted to go back home and forget about everything that happened.  But, the Capital, and even the Districts, won't let her go that easily.  The Capital wants her to bash the District's hopes, and the District's want her to bash in President Snow's face.

And thus the firebomb is lit.

But, there's a long trail of gunpowder between the spark and the firebomb.  So long, in fact, that it will take another entire book for the firebomb to eventually explode.

Katniss will lead the Rebellion as their Mockingjay.  More or less, she will win the Rebellion.  But, she will lose her sanity, even if it's only temporary.  Sorry to spoil it, guys.

The events that seals the fate of Panem is the death of a loved one during the Rebellion.  After that, one thing leads to another, and Katniss,herself, eventually ends up on trial for murder.  She's only saved by a plea of temporary insanity, which I actually thing is quite literally her exact situation.

But it all starts here, in Catching Fire, as Katniss Everdeen begins her spiraling descent into insanity.


The Fire Storm (is coming)

Remember how I've been saying I know next to nothing about Catching Fire and Mockingjay?  Well, I lied.


I know the general plot lines or both books, and the manner of death for some of the major characters.

THGians know what I'm talking about.

Everyone else is probably completely lost.

Taking what little knowledge I have into consideration, I think I can safely project as to how the third movie will end.

Remember, those wonderful guys over in Hollywood split the third book into two movies.

Which really shouldn't be surprising after Peter Jackson and Company managed to squeeze three movies out of one book.

I'll try to be very good and not drop too many spoilers for those who found themselves in the "completely lost" category.

There is a certain character who dies a tragic death in the third book.  This person's death, along with a bunch of other events and other deaths, cause Katniss to really lose her sanity (which then capitulates at the climax of the third book).

I have a theory.

I think the third movie will either end with or shortly after this character's death.

There will be an explosion.  Katniss and Company will search the wreckage, and there will be the body of said character.  Katniss will freak out and rush to lifeless body.  She will gather body in her arms and wail and cry, and the audience will either be in complete shock and crying as well.

Camera will cut into a close up of Katniss's tear streaked face.  She will look up at the camera with that same expression she gave us at the end of the second movie, and in that moment we will know beyond the shadow of a doubt that Katniss is tipped over the edge of sanity.

Cut to black.

Oh, misty eye of the mountain below...

Jennifer Lawrence

Keep careful watch of my brothers' souls...


Josh Hutcherson

And should the sky be filled with fire and smoke...


Liam Hemsworth

Keep watching over Durin's son...


You've been watching The Hunger Games: Mockingjay...part one


Tune in next year for the conclusion of the story.

Roll Credits

Other than the Hobbit references, I See Fire by Ed Sheeran would be perfect!  If for no other reasons than the fire references.

But, seriously, other than the music, I really think this is how the third THG movie is going to end.  I guess we'll find out in November.

Saturday, March 29, 2014

Noah: A Splash of the Apocalypse

The movie Noah opened in theaters at roughly 8pm Thursday night (March 28th, 2014).

Anti-Noah petitions have been showing up all over Facebook...for the past two months.  Two months.

The movie opened on Thursday night.

It has been protested for two months.  

Friday morning, I logged onto Facebook to find that one of the Christian pages had posted an advertisement for Noah.  It very innocently stated, "Noah hits theaters tomorrow".  I got on at 9am, and there were already 78 comments on the post bashing Noah, calling it a mockery, and expressing disappointment that this Christian site would advertise this horrible interpretation of the classic Bible story on Facebook.  Seventy-eight.

Did I already mention that the movie opened at 8pm Thursday night?

PluggedIn hadn't even reviewed it yet!

My opinion was, "Don't be so quick to judge something you haven't seen."  

Some agreed with me.  Some continued to rant.

So, I went to see Noah this afternoon.  

It was also my first Russell Crowe movie.

Here's Noah in a rather large nutshell:

In the Beginning, God created the Heavens and the Earth.  He eventually created man in His image, but they sinned and were cut off from God.  Adam and Eve had three sons, Cain, Abel, and Seth.  Cain killed Abel, and Cain's descendants spread out and pillaged and plundered like evil people.  Seth's descendants were good and relatively peaceful people who tried to counter the evil of Cain's descendants.  Fast forward some hundreds of years; young Noah and his nomad father are innocently out in the wilderness when a group of Cain's not-so-cool descendants arrive.  They kill Noah's father, but Noah is conveniently hiding behind a rock, and therefore the line of Seth is not ended as previously assumed.

Meanwhile, as humans began to spread out over the Earth, a group of angels got together and jointly decided that they were going to go to Earth and help the peoples out (with what, I don't know).  God was somehow angered by this, so He punished them by causing them to get trapped in stone encasements when they hit Earth.  They are now mutilated creatures of the Earth, which the movie refers to as fallen angels in the opening credit sequence.  Since then, they have been hunted down by men (whether these are the descendants of Cain or Seth is unclear), and the only person who defended them was Methuselah (yes, the same guy who lived to be over 969 years old).  They are now living, more or less, in seclusion in a barren wasteland at the base of a mountain off in the middle of Nowheresville. 

Flash forward.  Noah, now a husband and a father, lives in another barren Nowheresville.  While he and his two eldest sons, Shem and Ham, are gathering food, they encounter some of Cain's descendants who are hunting.  This being an adventure film, Noah kills them, and he and his sons give the dead animal a proper funeral.  Ham seems unhealthily interested in the fact that Cain's descendants eat animals, and this concerns Noah. 

That night, Noah has a freaky dream.  He sees himself standing in a muddy pile, but instead of water intermingled with dirt squishing between his toes, he finds his feet covered with blood.  He looks up and sees a mountain, which happens to be the current residence of his grandfather, Methuselah.  Seconds later, he's underwater, surrounded by dead and decaying human remains. 

So, Noah packs up his family and they all head out to visit dear old granddad Methuselah at his mountain residence.  Which isn't as easy as it sounds.  They have to pass through Cain-people territory to get there.  They're making good time until they come upon the remains of some people who have been butchered by Cain's descendants.  The only survivor, a young girl named Ila, is wounded and feverish.  Noah and his family adopt her in an act of rescue as they are all suddenly chased by more Cain-peoples who have been lurching in the area.  Their chase leads them into the Nowheresville occupied by the fallen angels, who then spring upon everyone, kill the Cain-people (it's effortless for them as they're huge and covered in solid rock), and dump Noah and his family in a pit to die.

One of them, however, helps Noah and his family escape and guides them safely to Methuselah's mountain.  There, it is revealed that Noah is to build an ark to save the animals (and his family) from the coming destruction.  After some convincing, the fallen angels agree to help Noah in this endeavor.  

And God makes a river explode from the ground, and it caused a forest to grow out of Nowheresville, which then provides them with the material to build their ark.  Yay!

Ten years later...I guess Noah can get a 140 year job done in 10 years with the help of the fallen angel rock peoples. 

Ila and Shem are deeply in love, but Ila's childhood wound has left her barren (not a good situation for someone who's supposed to help repopulate the Earth).  Ham is jealous because he doesn't have a girlfriend, and Japheth (who was a baby when this whole thing began) is old enough to help with the ark building and food gathering and such.  The whole thing is disrupted when a group of Cain people show up, led by Tubal-cain (did we mention that Tubal-cain murdered Noah's dad at the beginning of the movie?).  Tubal-cain and company camp on the other side of the miracle forest, and promptly break out in chaos.  

The ark is completed on schedule, and the rain starts pouring.  The Cain peoples, realizing that what Noah mentioned about impending doom by flood is probably true, set out to take the ark.  Noah hides his family in the ark with the animals, and fights off the Cain peoples with the help of the fallen angel rock people.  Water explodes out of the ground, and the flood comes.  Everyone outside is washed away, except for Tubal-cain who has managed to stow away on the ark with the animals.

In the middle of all of this, Ila discovers that she's pregnant with Shem's child, a miracle in and of itself.  But, for whatever reason, Noah has come to the conclusion that God never meant for man to survive at all, and therefore Noah and his family are to be the last people to walk the Earth.  In light of this and the news of Ila's pregnancy, Noah is determined to kill her baby.

Nine months later...there're still on the ark.  It has stopped raining, and everyone is beginning to hope that they could find solid land to live on soon.  Shem and Ila prepare to take off on a raft to escape from Noah, but Noah destroys their raft, and Ila goes into labor (perfect timing).  Surprise, surprise, surprise, Ila has twins.  Twin girls.  Noah is about to kill them, but then stops and says, "I can't do this."  At that moment, the dove arrives with an olive branch.

Tubal-cain tries to kill Noah, but Ham eventually manages to kill him.  End of corruption.

They land, make lives for themselves, Noah has a period of depression, and Ham leaves home (thinking that he's too violent and corrupt himself).  Noah eventually comes back to himself, and bestows his blessing on Shem and Ila's children.  There's a cool explosion thing in the sky, God's sign of approval, which pans out into a really cool and vibrant rainbow.

Roll credits.

Yeah, that was a huge nutshell.


Here's my opinion of Noah, in a much smaller nutshell:

I do not consider my 2 hours and 17 minutes to be wasted.   

I didn't think it was as bad as certain petitions made it out to be.  However, I'd classify it as one of those films that are really, really good, but need different titles.  It was a version of the Noah story.  It was more like a post-Apocalyptic version of the Biblical account.  I did find it interesting, though, that they showed Methuselah being alive at the time (I think I've seen timelines that show that he would have been alive during Noah's lifetime).  The film also showed the rest of mankind as being extremely corrupt, which is Biblically accurate (not just Evan Almighty, "Hey Weirdo with a Beardo!  How's the ark building coming along?", but serious, honest to goodness corruption).  

But, be warned; Noah is rated PG-13 for a reason.  

Borderline stereotypical blood-splatter (Game of Thrones fans know what I'm talking about) abounds in the film; it's like an ejective explosion of blood that spurs out of every single wound in an almost unrealistic manner.   

In the midst of all the corruption, there's actually no overly sexual content or nudity.  Well, okay, we see Noah lying naked on the beach from a distance, but nothing explicit is shown.  Also worth noting is that Adam and Eve are shown naked in the Garden of Eden, but their anatomy is masked by a sort of glowing angelic light that envelopes their bodies, and again we don’t see anything explicit.  There is an awful lot of kissing between Ila and Shem, though.  The most that is shown is a bare stomach and bare shoulders.  Nothing explicit.  Nothing overtly sexual.  

Noah is mercifully void of harsh language problems.  Tubal-cain uses the d-word twice, but it makes sense in the context of the story (it's in his catchphrase).  It was such a relief to get through a film without being bombarded by foul language. 

But, the most important thing to remember is this:  It's an interpretive version of a classic Biblical account, NOT a word-for-word retelling of the account itself.


Why are Christians so up in arms about Noah?

First of all, not all Christians hate the movie. 

I believe I am the first of my Christian friends to have seen Noah.  Those I have talked to agree that the film should not be judged until viewed.

Most of the anti-Noah rants I've read were written by people who haven't seen the movie, but have read about it (whether it be from Glenn Beck or someone else).  While I respect Mr. Beck's opinion, I still hold my own; Noah wasn't as bad as people made it out to be.

Those who are not Glenn Beck are concerned about Biblical inaccuracy, which is actually a valid point.  But, sometimes we Christians can get a little...oh, how shall I say this?...out of control with our feelings and convictions.  While there is nothing wrong with our convictions, there comes a time when we overstep even our God-appointed duties to speak up.  

Noah is the perfect example.

When have we overstepped the realms of sanity?

When we start threatening to burn people at the stake for not agreeing with our feelings about something.  (True story, there's an article on FB stating that "[We] should consider burning at the stake any Christian leaders who endorse this movie").  I consider that to be a bit radical (and not in a good way).  Especially since Jesus, himself, commanded us numerous times to love our enemies.  The above article doesn't sound very loving or Christ-like.  It sounds more like Fred Phelps than Jesus.

For all of those who have been quoting the Bible in defense of your Noah-hating/burn-at-the-stake comments, here's a Bible verse for you:

"But, I have this complaint against you.  You don't love me or each other as you did at first!" (Revelation 2:4, NLT)

If we are going to share the truth (in this case, our feelings about the inaccuracies in Noah), we should spend less time hating and boycotting the film, and spend more time doing research so we can calmly and maturely share our thoughts and feelings with those who may not know the truth.  Trust me, nothing turns someone off like, "I'm boycotting the movie because I heard from Bill who heard from Bob who read on Facebook that the movie sucked."

By the way, there's a boycott on FB now.  I'm one of the few people who have posted something not-negative about the movie.  I've probably just set myself up for major bashing, but that's okay.  It won't change my opinion.


Should Christians see Noah?

As I told my FB friends this evening, I think those of us Christians who know what we believe and have a firm foundation in Christ are safe seeing it, if for no other reason than intelligent discussion (What was Biblically accurate? What was interpretation or creative license? etc.).  Others who are new to Christianity or aren't as firmly grounded in their faith should be careful.


Okay, so what was Biblically accurate about Noah?

1. The Corruption of the Peoples

"Now God saw that the earth had become corrupt and was filled with violence.  God observed all this corruption in the world, for everyone on earth was corrupt."  (Genesis 6:11-12, NLT)

Evan Almighty fans and people who have grown up on children's classic Bible stories may think that "corruption" means people just not loving God and teasing Noah for building a huge boat in the desert.  I once saw a kid's claymation version that portrayed "corruption" as houses bouncing around (assuming the occupants were chaotic and unruly).

In reality, think Sodom and Gomorrah...tens times worse.

That is my new opinion of the word "corruption" in this context.

Things got so bad that God, the infinitely merciful and loving creator of everything, decided to wipe them out and start over.  Remember, Sodom and Gomorrah were bad enough that God rained fire down on them to destroy them.  This is the entire world we're talking about.

So, technically, the movie's portrayal of the world's corruption is probably pretty accurate.  

The Cain peoples are unruly and murderous.  There's a rather disturbing scene where Noah goes to their encampment to find wives for Ham and Japheth, and he witnesses people trading their wives and daughter for food.  Some men manage to knock over a fence and get their hands on a donkey, and literally rip the poor thing to shreds while it's still alive.

By the way, no real animals were hurt in the making of this movie, if that makes the PETA people feel better.


2. God's Mercy 

Rewind to when God looked down and saw that the peoples of the Earth had become corrupt and He decided to wipe them out and start over.  Now, He could have just tossed a fiery bomb at us and blown up the planet, but He didn't.  Instead, He told Noah to build a big boat and put two of every animal in it so in order to preserve life.  Noah, his family, and the animals on board are to repopulate the Earth after the flood, and those God's creation isn't entirely annihilated, only purged of corruption.

"So God said to Noah, "I have decided to destroy all living creatures, for they have filled the earth with violence.  Yes, I will wipe them all out along with the earth.  Build a large boat from cypress wood and waterproof it with tar, inside and out [...] Look!  I am about to cover the earth with a flood that will destroy every living thing that breathes.  Everything on earth will die.  But I will confirm my covenant with you.  So enter the boat — you and your wife and your sons and their wives.  Bring a pair of every kind of animal — a male and a female — into the boat with you to keep them alive.””  (Genesis 6:13-14a, 17-19, NLT)

Although the name of God is never actually spoken in the movie, and God is generally referred to as "The Creator", it was still clear (at least it was to me) who we were talking about.  God, the Creator of all things.  The God who breathed life into everything and brought the world into existence just by speaking.  The same God who saved eight people and two of every animal is the same God as the one who sent His only Son to die on a cross for our sins.


3. Methuselah

While this is not actually mentioned in the Bible, I have read articles and seen charts that indicate that Methuselah would have been alive at the same time that Noah was building the ark.  So, it was kinda cool to see Methuselah pop up once in a while in the movie.


4. The Flood

Duh...


5. The Rainbow

...another "duh".  Although, it was shown in a very unique and vivid way.  


6. Noah Getting Drunk Afterwards

This is one of those things I wish they'd left out, but they put it in.  I guess most movies based on other text (whether it be Lord of the Rings or The Bible) have those scenes where we're like, "Well that's the one accurate part I wish they'd been inaccurate about."  In context, it sort of has a purpose, though.  

Again, while this is not actually mentioned in the Bible, the movie suggests the concept that Noah was so emotionally distraught after watching all of humanity die that he suffered a sort of nervous break down that may have caused temporary insanity.  This may explain why, in the movie, he convinced himself that God wanted him to kill Ila and Shem's daughters.  This may also explain why he goes off to a cave and gets drunk once everything is dried out and they're back on solid ground again.  The Bible doesn't indicate this, but it is still an interesting concept.


Other Things Worth Mentioning

1. The Watchers

Whoa, whoa, hold on!  The what???  

Okay, so I kind of forgot to mention that the movie also referred to the stone giant "fallen angel" peoples as The Watchers.  

I first heard about the Watchers in one of my favorite Christian novels, Dragons in Our Midst.  In those books, they are portrayed as fallen angels who have married humans, who are purely evil and are trying to take over the world.  In light of what I've read in those books, I was interested to see the Watcher's incorporated into the Noah movie.

In the movie, however, the Watchers are portrayed as remorseful angels who got stuck on Earth after coming down to help mankind.  They hoped and prayed for years that God would forgive them, and let them come back to Heaven, but to no avail...yet.

My thoughts: It's a Return of the King moment.

Side trip: In Return of the King, there is mention of an army that Isildur rallied to aid them in the battle against Sauron.  But, this army fled at the last minute and hid out in the mountains.  So, Isildur cursed them, so that they could never sleep until they had fulfilled their oaths.  Aragorn goes to rally the dead army to aid Rohan in defeating the armies of Sauron on the Pelennor Fields because he's Isildur's heir, and therefore the only living person with the right to rally them, and the ability to set them free.  They eventually agree to follow him into battle on the Pelennor Fields, and after the battle is won, Aragorn declares, "I hold your oaths fulfilled," and the dead army can finally actually, well, die.

It seems like the same kind of thing here.  God allowed them to be stuck on Earth for a time.  They said they wanted to help the humans, but the humans have hunted them down and killed some of them, so they gave up and hid in the wilderness.  They finally help Noah build the ark, and - although it's not said in the movie - I can image God saying, "I hold your oaths fulfilled," before He allows them to break free of their stony bodies and return to Heaven.  Again, there is no evidence of this in the Bible, or in the movie.  But, it is a concept.

Another thing about the Watchers: Genesis 6 mentions the Nephilim, who were apparently some kind of fallen angels that mated with humans (or were the Nephilim their children?).  Regardless, the Nephilim were giants, and Genesis clearly states that they were around at the time of Noah, and after the Flood.  The biggest evidence that the Nephilim were still around after the Flood is when the Israelites go to spy out the Promise Land, and come back with reports of freakishly tall giants.  So, the argument could be made that if the Nephilim were actual fallen angels (or the descendants of fallen angels), they could return to Earth and start all over again after the Flood.  

So, it is possible that this stone-encased "fallen angels" are the filmmaker's interpretation of the Nephilim?  It would make sense, since they're giants.  Food for thought.


2. Sin

Most non-Christians are of the opinion that man is basically good.  They’ll believe Pandora’s Box before they’ll admit that man brought sin into the world (as stated in Genesis). 

Noah is very adamant; man brought sin into the world when Adam and Eve disobeyed God and ate the forbidden fruit.    

I applaud these guys for not shying away from the issue!

Of course, they also take it to the extreme where Noah assumes that God means to forever rid the world of mankind because they were the ones who broke the rules to begin with.  This thinking leads to the almost murder of Ila and Shem's babies, but Noah eventually comes to his senses and realizes that he and his family have been preserved in order to repopulate the Earth after the Flood.


My Biggest Problem

Yes, I have one big issue with Noah.  And it is this; they gave Methuselah way too much power in the movie.

He's portrayed as some sort of magician who can work up magic sleeping potions and make you fall asleep by breathing on you.

The whole thing is most evident concerning Ila's pregnancy.  He says he's going to give her his blessing.  What he does is tough her stomach, and it is implied that she is magically healed of her barrenness by his touch.

Before that, Noah's wife goes to Methuselah and asks him to make it possible for Ila and Shem to have children.  She doesn't even bother checking with God.  She just goes to "all-powerful Grandpa Methuselah".  And he doesn't try to say, "Yo lady, God's the guy you should be asking."  All he says is something like, "This is probably going to end tragically for you guys."  Which it almost does.

My point: I really wish they'd have given the power to it's rightful owner, God, instead of making Methuselah out to be an all-powerful magician.


Conclusion

So, Noah was definitely interesting and not a waste of time. 

It was more of a post-Apocalyptic version of the Noah story. If you're expecting a word-for-word retelling of the Biblical account, you'll be disappointed. 

However, Noah was a good, well-made movie in and of itself. And there was some Biblical accuracy in the film (the animals came two by two, God told Noah in a dream about the flood, the other peoples were extremely corrupt, and the rainbow still appeared in the sky afterward). 

I will leave it up to you to decide whether or not to see Noah, in theaters or ever.  I could tell you one way or the other, but that decision really needs to be between you and God.  

If you do go, view it as a twist on a story as opposed to a direct visual interpretation of the Biblical account.  View it skeptically and critically, analyze everything, so that you will be better able to answer when others ask you about your opinions of the film (and you'll be better equipped to tell others the truth about the story). 

 If you don't go, then please, please, please do your research before bashing the film.  Read reviews from valuable sources.  Listen to people who have seen it.  And, above all else, don't start ranting and raving like a maniac (that's the best way to turn people off, I should know).

Either way, we should use Noah as a learning experience, to teach us how to articulate our thoughts and convictions in a loving, Jesus-like way.  If we're supposed to be Jesus to the world, then maybe we should start acting like it.


And, I still did not consider my 2 hours and 17 minutes to have been wasted. 

Friday, March 14, 2014

Thursday, March 13, 2014

J.R.R. Tolkien reads from The Hobbit

Greetings!



I was overly excited when I found this.  Why, you may be asking?  This is a recording of Tolkien (the man, himself) reading an excerpt from The Hobbit.  For those of us who were born way after Mr. Tolkien's departure from the world, this is the closest some of us will ever get to the Mastermind of Middle Earth.  Please do take sixteen minutes and enjoy!












Thursday, February 6, 2014

The Various Character Journeys of Mr. Bilbo Baggins...continued

Wow, now I'm hung up on Bilbo.  But, why not?  He is, after all, the title character (being the only Hobbit in the Company of Thorin Oakenshield).

But, in case you're wondering, I still have a major crush on Thorin!

Back to our friend Bilbo.

As I sat here, slaving away at my homework, my mind began to wander, and I began to think about some Hobbit/LOTR fan art I really like.  Here are a few of the images that came to mind:




These stood out to me not just because little Frodo is so adorable, but because I noticed the tenderness they portray.  This is a moment we don't actually see in The Hobbit or LOTR.  In fact, some might say they're inaccurate to the actual story as Frodo wasn't adopted until he was almost twenty (still a teenager by Hobbit standards).  But, even so, these images evoke a certain emotion that we, as fans, readers, and viewers, can imagine and believe, even though we don't actually get to see moments like these in the story itself.

First of all, the above images depict a closeness between Bilbo and Frodo.  Frodo has, at this point, lost his family (his parents died in a terrible boating accident).  After their deaths, he lived with his Brandybuck relations over in Buckland, and he is later taken in by Bilbo.

As a side note, Frodo's adoption is never flaunted.  It's only mentioned in passing at the beginning of the Fellowship (book) as an explanation for how Frodo got there in the first place (as it is presumed that Bilbo never married).  Frodo never says anything about it, Bilbo doesn't say anything about it, and it isn't brought up or used as a trigger point toward Frodo by anyone throughout Middle Earth.  In fact, the only people who really make a big deal about it are Bilbo's notably obnoxious relatives, the Sackville-Bagginses.  "You don't belong here," Lobelia Sackville-Baggins tells Frodo in the Fellowship, "you're no Baggins - you — you're a Brandybuck".  Which isn't entirely true since Frodo's father was also a Baggins.  And, even if it hadn't been, Frodo would have inherited the Baggins name when he was adopted by Bilbo.  And the only reason they make a big deal out of it is that, if Frodo hadn't been adopted, they would have inherited Bag End when Bilbo [eventually] kicked the bucket.

Second, the above images portray a certain tender side of Bilbo we haven't seen before in either LOTR or the Hobbit (books and movies).  It's a sort of fatherly affection which we can only image Bilbo could possess, but we never actually see it (partially because we come into their relationship so late in the game by the time the Fellowship begins).  In these images, I can tell Bilbo genuinely cares about Frodo, and Gandalf even states that Bilbo would never give Frodo anything he thought might harm him (in reference to the Ring).  This is the tender hearted, selfless side of Bilbo, who takes a potentially high-energy young Hobbit into his home just because Frodo needed a home.

Granted, of course, Frodo had a home in Buckland, but his adoption by Bilbo seems to have been more official.  

It is noted in the Fellowship that Frodo was Bilbo's favorite cousin, so we can safely assume that they already knew each other very well, and had already formed a closeness that neither shared with any of their other Hobbit relations.  Whether or not this was an actual father/son relationship is never clearly stated in the books (or the movies).

But, as I continued to slave away at my homework, I began to wonder about this father/son relationship between Bilbo and Frodo respectively.  More specifically, would the Mr. Bilbo Baggins we met at the beginning of An Unexpected Journey have been this selfless?  Would Bilbo have been a good father figure for Frodo if he hadn't gone on his quest and had all of his adventures with Thorin and Company?

Taking into consideration the kind of guy Bilbo was when we first met, I'd be inclined to say no.

Why?

Bilbo isn't up for anything that might interrupt his very delicate routine (adventures were out of the question).  As we prepare to welcome my stepmom into our family, I realized that I will be an Aunt in a week.  I've already met my future niece, who is three years old.  Not only this, but I've worked with children ranging in age from infants to four years.  Children, though adorable, are a lot of work.  I can't imagine the "old" Bilbo Baggins even considering taking on the responsibility of raising a child (even if said child was almost twenty), even more so if we're talking about a young child (as depicted in the above images).

I think the pre-adventures Bilbo would not have had the patience to deal with Frodo, especially if we imagine that Frodo was a little kid at the time of his adoption.  Even if Frodo was an older kid (Hobbit equivalent teenager), I don't think Bilbo would have agreed to take him in, or would have done so with great reluctance.  Having another person (or Hobbit) in the house would have disrupted his schedule and routine.  Adopting a younger Hobbit kid would have been completely out of the question.

Another thing to think about: Bilbo, as far as I can tell from the books, became popular with the younger Hobbits because of his stories about his adventures.  While all the grown-up Hobbits waved his tales off as "uncanny", the children flocked to him, and listened in wide-eyed fascination to his accounts of his experience with Thorin and Company.  If not for Gandalf sending Bilbo on the quest with the Dwarves, Bilbo would have been just another adult Hobbit who was very sensible, neat, and organized, the kind of Hobbit who thought that children should be seen and not heard, and who frowned upon stories of dragons and elves as "uncanny" and ridiculous, and therefore not worth the time.  I think it is safe to assume that Bilbo would not have been a favorite among the younger Hobbits if he'd lived a normal Hobbit life.  In fact, there would be no need to tell his story, as nothing unexpected would ever happen (save for the occasional marriage invitation or burnt muffin).  Not much as a story there, at all.

And if there's no story, then there's no book.  And if there's no Hobbit book, then there's no Lord of the Rings.

Luckily, Tolkien had others plans.  Because Bilbo did go on his adventures, and he did find a magic Ring in a cave in the mountains, and he did become very popular with the kids because of his stories, and he did adopt Frodo (however old Frodo was).

But, it is my opinion that Bilbo would not have even been open to the idea of adopting Frodo if he hadn't gone on his adventures with Thorin and Company.  Even bigger than his character journey where the Ring is concerned and how the Ring changed him, the Quest for Erebor in and of itself changed him in many ways as well.  To be specific, he became more selfless during his adventures.

Evidence?

When the Dwarves are kidnapped by the spiders, he could have left them.  He could have disregarded anything Gandalf had already said or might say, and escaped the situation with his life.  But, he didn't.  He stayed behind and risked his life to save his friends.

When the Dwarves are captured by the Elves of Mirkwood and thrown in prison, Bilbo could have stayed behind and let them be taken.  He could have let the Elves lead him out of the forest, and left the Dwarves to rot in prison.  But, he didn't.  He snuck into the Elven palace, and hangs around for months as he tries to devise a way to help his friends escape.  He's the one who finds all of their thirteen cells, and he's the one who figures out that Thorin is also a prison of Thranduil (in the book, Thorin was captured beforehand, and the other Dwarves don't know what happened to him).  And, in the end, he's the one who gets them out of Mirkwood, and doesn't even considering getting out himself until the very, very last minute (the one glitch in his brilliant escape plan).

And thus, Mr. Bilbo Baggins's character journey isn't just one controlled by a circular piece of shiny gold metal.  It is one that changes Bilbo's life in ways I doubt even he expected.  He doesn't just come back as the richest Hobbit in the Shire and the Bearer of the One Ring, but also as a humble and selfless one.

Bilbo came back from his adventures with a bigger heart.  The adventures made him more open to doing things that might upset his routine.  When Frodo's parents die, he's the one who says, "Well, you better come live with me, Frodo, my lad."  And he takes Frodo in willingly, not out of obligation or because he really doesn't want the Sackville-Bagginses to inherit Bag End.  It's a genuine, selfless love, and one that wasn't there before his adventures.

And, Frodo learns a lot from Bilbo's example.  Frodo, himself, is generally selfless and popular with his younger cousins, notably Merry and Pippin, both of him later accompany him on his own Quest in LOTR.  When faced with the reality that he'll now have to take the Ring to Mordor, Frodo can't bear to ask any of his friends (or cousins) to go with him.  He knows, somehow, that this is a hopeless Quest, and that, even if the Ring is destroyed, Frodo himself still probably won't make it home again. By then, he's willing to sacrifice himself to save the world, and (even though he is afraid) he is willing to do it alone.  It is only Sam's stubborn determination and loyalty that make Frodo finally agree to take him along.

Frodo may have had this selflessness already, but it is my opinion that it was nourished and fully matured by Bilbo's example, as Frodo observed Bilbo's own selflessness.

This tender, loving, fatherly side of Bilbo is one that was he may not have known about, himself, but it is one that is revealed by the selflessness he brought home as a result of his adventures.  And, it is one that may never have come to light if he'd stayed home.